So… I’ve bought some shoes… I wear a 13 4e, so my purchases are focused on fit first…
Footjoy flex fit… these are a little weird… fit is great, I don’t love the lacing and how they tighten. Definitely not waterproof. Very comfortable for golf when it’s dry.
Sketchers BOA: waterproof. Pretty comfortable! The BOA is ok, but I’m still getting used to it… they were also $100.
Footjoy traditions: just got these and really like them… fit and comfort is great. 1 year waterproof warranty… only problem is they are VERY white and that’s the only option in my size… I bought new socks because my white calf socks with bright white shoes looks terrible… probably should have just combined the sock budget with the shoe budget and gotten an expensive pair of footjoy… oh well. For a $130 they are very comfortable and I’m hoping will work for me long term.